Gnosticism and Its Historical Context
Mike Ervin

            Gnosticism and Its Historical Context

In this teaching we rely heavily on a course from the Teaching Company created by Professor David Brakke at Ohio State University. His research includes ancient Christianity, early monasticism, and the formation of the biblical canon. ​He has published extensively, including works on Gnosticism and has held various academic fellowships.

The teaching below represents a comprehensive summary of Professor  Brakke’s Teaching Company publication.

For Starters:

Gnosticism represents a complex and diverse set of beliefs in early Christianity, emphasizing direct knowledge of God and often opposing orthodox teachings.

• Gnosticism is derived from the Greek word "gnosis," meaning knowledge, particularly direct knowledge of God. ​
• The term "Gnosticism" was coined in the 17th century, but the movement itself dates back to the first few centuries A.D. ​
• Gnostics believed the material world was flawed and created by a lower, inferior god, contrasting with the ultimate, spiritual God.
• The Nag Hammadi codices, discovered in 1945, contain significant Gnostic texts that provide insights into their beliefs and practices. ​

The Nag Hammadi Codices Discovery

The Nag Hammadi codices are a collection of Gnostic texts that significantly enhance our understanding of early Christian diversity.

• Discovered in 1945 in Egypt, the codices consist of 52 texts, with 46 distinct works. ​
• They include various genres such as apocalypses, theological treatises, and gospels, many of which reinterpret biblical narratives.
• The texts are primarily written in Coptic, a language developed by Christians in Egypt, and were likely copied between 350 and 450 A.D. ​
• The codices reveal the existence of multiple Gnostic schools of thought, including the Valentinian school. ​

Irenaeus of Lyon's Role

Irenaeus of Lyon was a key figure in early Christianity, known for his opposition to Gnostic teachings and his efforts to define orthodoxy. ​

• He wrote "Against the Heresies," a work aimed at refuting Gnostic beliefs and establishing a unified Christian doctrine. ​
• Irenaeus described Gnostic myths, emphasizing their view of a flawed creator god and the ultimate God. ​
• His writings highlight the diversity of early Christianity, challenging the notion of a singular, original Christian truth. ​
• Irenaeus's perspective has shaped historical views on heresy and orthodoxy in Christianity. ​

Common Gnostic Beliefs and Myths

Gnosticism is characterized by a set of shared beliefs that challenge traditional views of God and the material world.

• Gnostics believed the material universe was inherently flawed and created by a lesser god, often referred to as the Demiurge.
• They emphasized the importance of self-knowledge and the idea that true selves are spiritual rather than material.
• Gnostic myths often reinterpret biblical stories, presenting a narrative where knowledge (gnosis) leads to salvation. ​
• The Gnostic view of God includes multiple divine emanations, or aeons, and a focus on the ultimate unknowable God. ​

The Secret Book According to John

The "Secret Book According to John" is a foundational Gnostic text that outlines the Gnostic myth and conception of God. ​

• It presents a revelation from the Savior to John, detailing the creation of the world and the nature of God. ​
• The text emphasizes the unknowability of the ultimate God, referred to as the Invisible Spirit.
• It portrays the material world as dominated by evil rulers, contrasting with the hope of salvation through knowledge of the true God.
• The narrative serves as a comprehensive account of Gnostic beliefs, linking creation, sin, and salvation in a unique theological framework. ​

Gnostic View of God and Creation

The Gnostics presented a complex understanding of God, creation, and the nature of humanity, emphasizing a distinction between the ultimate God and a flawed creator deity. ​

• The Invisible Spirit is the ultimate God, eternally at rest and unknowable. ​
• Forethought, a thought of the Invisible Spirit, is the first emanation and represents the highest aspect of God that can be known. ​
• Human beings are believed to originate from Forethought and are destined to return to it. ​
• The Gnostic creation myth involves Wisdom (Sophia) acting independently, leading to the creation of an imperfect being, Yaldabaoth, who creates the material world.
• The Gnostics view the material world as flawed and a poor imitation of the spiritual realm. ​

The Role of Wisdom in Gnosticism

Wisdom plays a dual role in Gnostic thought, being both a source of enlightenment and the cause of humanity's fall.

• Wisdom is depicted as a female figure who enlightens humanity about their divine origins. ​
• Her independent thought leads to the creation of Yaldabaoth, the flawed creator god. ​
• The Gnostics believe that her error disturbs the harmony of the spiritual realm.
• Wisdom's actions result in the creation of the material world, which is seen as inferior.

Gnostic Retelling of Biblical Stories

Some Gnostic texts reinterpret biblical narratives to align with their beliefs about creation, sin, and salvation. ​

• The Secret Book According to John retells Genesis, correcting perceived errors in the traditional account. ​
• The Gnostic creation story emphasizes the dual creation of humanity, first as a spiritual being and then as a physical one.
• The flood narrative is reinterpreted to highlight the failure of the creator god and the salvation of the "seed of Seth."
• Gnostic texts often portray the creator god as ignorant and malevolent, contrasting with the true divine realm.

The Gospel of Judas and Its Significance

The Gospel of Judas presents a unique perspective on Judas Iscariot, portraying him as a tragic hero rather than a villain. ​

• The text claims that Jesus revealed profound truths to Judas, making him a privileged disciple. ​
• Judas's betrayal is framed as a necessary act for the fulfillment of divine plans. ​
• The Gospel critiques the other disciples, depicting them as ignorant of true spiritual knowledge. ​
• Judas is seen as a figure who will play a significant role in the cosmic reorganization of the universe. ​

Gnostic Rituals and Practices

Gnostic rituals, particularly baptism, are central to their beliefs and practices, symbolizing spiritual awakening and knowledge. ​

• Baptism is described as a transformative act that connects individuals to the divine.
• Gnostic texts outline various rituals, including washing, enthroning, and glorifying. ​
• The Holy Book of the Great Invisible Spirit emphasizes the importance of baptism in achieving gnosis. ​
• Hymns and liturgical practices are integral to Gnostic worship, guiding participants toward spiritual enlightenment. ​

The Feminine Divine in Gnostic Texts

Gnostic literature features significant feminine elements, presenting a more inclusive view of the divine compared to orthodox traditions. ​

• The Secret Book describes the Barbelo as both a mother and a powerful divine figure.
• Wisdom (Sophia) is portrayed as a key figure who both enlightens and causes the fall of humanity.
• The Thunder: Perfect Intellect features a female revealer who embodies paradoxical qualities.
• The Reality of the Rulers highlights the feminine divine and the sexual violence faced by women, complicating the portrayal of femininity in Gnostic thought. ​

Gnostic Views on Sexuality and Women

Gnostic myth generally portrays sexual desire negatively, associating it with sinfulness and the influence of evil rulers. ​

• Gnostic texts depict sexual desire as a motivating force for evil rulers to lead humanity astray. ​
• Instances of sexual intercourse in Gnostic narratives, such as Adam and Eve producing Seth, are exceptions rather than the rule.
• Early Christians, including Paul, also held negative views on sexual desire, promoting celibacy and viewing sex for pleasure as wrong. ​
• Marriage was acceptable, but reproduction was the only good reason for sexual relations.

The Gospel According to Thomas Overview

The Gospel of Thomas is a collection of sayings attributed to Jesus, emphasizing personal insight and knowledge of the divine.

• Scholars debate the dating of the Gospel of Thomas, with some suggesting it predates the New Testament gospels. ​
• The text is not a narrative but a wisdom book, presenting Jesus as a voice of divine wisdom. ​
• It teaches that the kingdom of God is within individuals, emphasizing self-knowledge and the recognition of one's true self.
• The gospel rejects apocalyptic eschatology, asserting that the kingdom of God is present now, not a future event. ​

Differences Between Thomas and Gnostic Texts

The Gospel of Thomas shares some similarities with Gnostic thought but lacks its complex mythology and rituals. ​

• Thomas emphasizes self-knowledge as a path to understanding God, differing from Gnostic views that focus on the distance from God. ​
• The text does not include the intricate divine hierarchy found in Gnostic myths.
• Thomas promotes the idea that the divine light is within all individuals, aligning with Gnostic beliefs but without the same mythological framework. ​
• Most scholars hesitate to label Thomas as Gnostic due to its distinct teachings and lack of Gnostic rituals. ​

Valentinianism and Its Influence

Valentinus was a significant figure in early Christianity, blending Gnostic thought with Christian teachings to create a lasting movement. ​

• Born around 100 CE, Valentinus became a prominent teacher in Rome by 140 CE. ​
• His teachings emphasized personal experience of God and the divine potential within humanity. ​
• Valentinus's writings, though mostly lost, influenced many early Christian theologians and contributed to the development of Christian thought.
• His version of Gnostic myth was more explicitly Christian and less anti-Jewish than earlier Gnostic narratives.

Valentinian Rituals and Practices

Valentinian rituals, including baptism and the Eucharist, were integral to their understanding of salvation and spiritual union. ​

• Baptism involved a period of preparation, immersion in water, and anointing with oil, symbolizing liberation from the material world. ​
• The Eucharist was seen as a means to gain knowledge of the Father and participate in the divine. ​
• The concept of the "bridal chamber" symbolized the reunion of male and female spiritual selves, reflecting their understanding of salvation. ​
• The ritual of ransom prepared dying individuals for their spiritual ascent, emphasizing the separation of spirit from matter. ​

Valentinian Views on Resurrection

Valentinians held a unique perspective on resurrection, focusing on the spiritual rather than the physical aspect of life after death. ​

• They believed that only the spirit would enter the Fullness, as matter was seen as corruptible and temporary.
• Resurrection was viewed as a process of returning to the spiritual realm, rather than a physical resurrection of the body. ​
• The teachings emphasized that individuals could experience resurrection in the present by recognizing their true spiritual nature. ​
• This view contrasted with traditional Christian beliefs about bodily resurrection, highlighting the Valentinians' distinct theological stance. ​

The Role of the Jewish Bible in Early Christianity

The early Christians grappled with the relevance of the Jewish Bible as Gentile believers began to dominate the faith. ​

• Paul and early believers believed Gentiles could follow Christ without converting to Judaism. ​
• By the 2nd century, many Gentile Christians questioned the relevance of the Jewish Bible. ​
• Marcion argued that the Old Testament was irrelevant, depicting its God as harsh and punitive.
• Gnostics believed the Bible contained errors and required correction, particularly in Genesis. ​
• Irenaeus maintained that the Old Testament was inspired and integral to understanding Jesus. ​

Valentinian Perspectives on the Old Testament

Valentinian theologians offered a nuanced view of the Old Testament, distinguishing between divine and human elements.

• Ptolemy, a Valentinian, argued that the Old Testament did not come from the ultimate perfect God. ​
• He categorized Old Testament laws into three types: pure but imperfect, unjust, and symbolic.
• Ptolemy emphasized that only the divine elements of the Old Testament apply to Christians. ​

Mary Magdalene's Prominence in Early Christianity

Mary Magdalene emerged as a significant figure in alternative Christian texts, often portrayed in contrast to male apostles. ​ 

• The Gospel According to Philip refers to her as "the apostle to the apostles." ​
• Mary is depicted as having a special relationship with Jesus, raising questions among male disciples. ​
• The Gospel of Mary highlights her role in teaching and revealing Jesus's messages, challenging male authority. ​

Competing Revelations and Early Christian Authority

The emergence of new revelations in early Christianity led to debates over authority and the nature of truth. ​

• Montanus and his followers claimed to receive new revelations, leading to the New Prophecy movement. ​
• Some Christians accepted these revelations, while others, like Irenaeus, rejected them as heretical. ​
• Revelations attributed to apostles like Paul and Peter were found in Nag Hammadi texts, sparking further controversy. ​

Irenaeus's Defense Against Heresy

Irenaeus developed a framework to combat heretical teachings and establish orthodox Christianity. ​

• He emphasized apostolic succession, tracing true teachings back to the apostles. ​
• Irenaeus argued that all true teachings were publicly available and not reserved for a select few. ​
• He promoted a unified Christian canon, advocating for the use of the four gospels and the letters of Paul.

Origen's Alternative Path to Gnosticism

Origen offered a more intellectual approach to Christianity, seeking to reconcile faith with philosophical inquiry. ​

• He believed in a single path toward truth, allowing for varying levels of understanding among Christians. ​
• Origen's theology emphasized God's love and the potential for all beings to return to Him. ​
• He proposed a vision of salvation that included the eventual restoration of all rational beings.

Gnosticism's Jewish Roots

Scholars suggest that Gnosticism may have originated from Jewish thought before incorporating Christian elements. ​

• Early Jewish thinkers like Philo presented ideas of multiple divine powers, influencing Gnostic thought. ​
• Gnostic texts often engage deeply with the Jewish Bible, particularly Genesis, while correcting perceived errors. ​
• The transition from Jewish to Gnostic thought may have been catalyzed by the historical context of Jewish suffering. ​

Hermeticism as a Non-Christian Gnostic Parallel

Hermeticism emerged as a spiritual movement parallel to Gnosticism, focusing on divine knowledge and enlightenment. ​

• Hermetic texts, attributed to Hermes Trismegistus, emphasize the soul's divine nature and the quest for knowledge. ​
• The Hermetic view shares similarities with Gnostic thought, such as the belief in a higher, immaterial self. ​
• Unlike Gnosticism, Hermeticism does not incorporate Jesus Christ into its teachings or mythology.

The Nature of Humanity in Hermeticism

Humanity is viewed as both immortal and mortal, reflecting its divine origin and material existence. ​

• Humanity is immortal due to its divine origin. ​
• Humanity is mortal because of its connection to the material world. ​
• Initially, humans were androgynous, later separated into male and female by God for procreation. ​
• Two types of people exist: those who love the body and remain ignorant, and those who recognize their divine intellect and seek self-improvement. ​
• Good individuals ascend to God after death, becoming divine powers.

Plotinus and Neoplatonism

Plotinus introduced Neoplatonism, emphasizing humanity's essential connection to God rather than alienation. ​

• Plotinus believed in a remote source of all existence called The One. ​
• The One generates Intellect, which in turn produces Soul, leading to the emanation of all reality. ​
• The material world is not entirely separate from spiritual reality; everything exists on a continuum.
• The body is a manifestation of the true self, which is layered and connected to The One. ​
• Awareness of our connection to The One can be cultivated through philosophy and disciplined living. ​

Iamblichus and Theurgy

Iamblichus diverged from Plotinus by asserting that the soul is completely fallen and requires purification. ​

• Iamblichus distinguished between the soul and intellect, with the soul acting as an intermediary. ​
• The soul must be purified and restored to its previous condition through theurgy, involving rituals with material elements. ​
• Material objects can symbolize divine power and help the soul experience the divine. ​

Manichaeism: A Global Gnostic Religion

Manichaeism emerged as a global Gnostic religion, emphasizing the struggle between Good and Evil rather than direct acquaintance with God. ​

• Founded by Mani, who claimed to be the Paraclete and the culmination of all prophecy. ​
• Mani's teachings included a dualistic worldview of Good (Light) and Evil (Darkness). ​
• The Manichaean church had a hierarchical structure with Elect and Hearers, each with different levels of purity and lifestyle. ​
• The Elect lived ascetically, while Hearers led more conventional lives but supported the Elect.

Augustine's Critique of Manichaeism

Augustine, a former Manichaean, developed Christian doctrines in opposition to Manichaean beliefs. ​

• He argued against the dualistic view of Good and Evil as eternal principles.
• Augustine posited that evil is a lack of good, not an independent force. ​
• He introduced the concept of original sin, claiming all humanity inherits sin from Adam and Eve.
• Augustine emphasized the necessity of divine grace for salvation and the idea of predestination. ​

Gnostic Themes in Western Religions

Gnostic and Valentinian themes have persisted in Western religious history, influencing various movements and philosophies. ​

• Myth-making, Gnosis, and dualism are key features that reappear in later religious traditions. ​
• The Mandaeans continue the tradition of Gnostic myth-making, emphasizing rituals for connecting with the realm of light. ​
• Kabbalah shares similarities with Gnostic thought, focusing on the unknowable nature of God and the emanation of divine attributes. ​

Gnosticism's Influence on Modern Culture

Gnosticism has inspired modern literature and film, reflecting themes of alienation and the search for true identity. ​

• Philip K. Dick's works explore Gnostic ideas of reality and self-identity. ​
• The Matrix film illustrates Gnostic themes of awakening to a false reality and discovering one's true nature. ​
• The Ecclesia Gnostica represents a contemporary Gnostic Christian church, blending traditional rituals with a quest for Gnosis. ​

Ongoing Debates About Gnosticism

Scholars debate the categorization and definition of Gnosticism, highlighting its diversity and historical significance. ​

• Some argue that Gnosticism is a distinct system of belief, while others see it as a collection of related ideas. ​
• The Nag Hammadi texts reveal a wide variety of Gnostic thought, complicating the understanding of a singular Gnostic tradition. ​

The quest for Gnosis and the creation of mythology are seen as enduring elements in Western religious history.

Gnosticism and Its Historical Context

                                       Links
                             <<    Home     >>